JAHA main website

Education Materials

A Canine Hero?

No one knows for sure whether this hero story is true or not. The little girl in this photo was saved from drowning in the flood when her family’s dog swam to her and towed her to safety.

Based on what you know about the Flood, dogs, and the relationship of dogs to their families, what about this story is likely true? What seems unlikely> What questions would you ask?

A little girl and her dog

Even though it is impossible for us to go back and interview this family, the photograph has clues in it that can help us form a solid opinion of whether the story is true.

Research and think about:

  • Check the American Kennel Club website.
  • What breed is the dog? Why does it have that unusual haircut? What dogs today have their coats trimmed in styles similar to this? (HINT: What do poodles and portuguese water dogs have in common from their past?)
  • Which of the breeds that look similar to the dog in the photo are strong swimmers? Would any of these been known in Johnstown in 1889?
  • Does your research help answer questions about the truth of this story? What do you think — is it true or not?